schussman.com logo

He makes this stuff up so I don't have to

They let the Darwin guy write another letter to the editor:

Another Darwin’s theory: Could I please enlist the help of any animal behaviorists out there? If I teach a troop of chimpanzees to carry a gallon paint bucket, a brush and let them practice on my home, how long before I have a professional crew that I can go into the painting business with? I think it will take a long time, but that’s Darwin’s theory.

Another Darwin’s theory: Could I please enlist the help of any mathematical geniuses of probable cause out there? If I completely dismantled my 17-jewel Rolex watch with a 69-diamond-faced sapphire crystal, put it into my whirl-wind vacuum with all the components of a storage cell battery, and turn it off and on every 60 seconds starting at noon today, how long will I have to wait before my watch tells the correct time? I think it would take a long time, but that’s Darwin’s theory.

Another Darwin’s theory: Could I please enlist the help of any top contractual lawyers out there? If I open a chimpanzee hand carwash, are my employees subject to state labor-agreement laws and anti-strike clauses? How can I avoid a company takeover and keep my chimpanzees from starting their own franchise if they evolve too quickly, then decide to start some new monkey business? I think they might try to overtake my business in time, but that’s Darwin’s theory.

I am impressed by the increasingly Rube Goldbergian quality to this entry, what with the “storage cell battery” and the “whird-wind vacuum,” and I admit that we might all be cheered by the prospect of an all-chimpanzee paint crew willing to do the painting jobs that Americans refuse. But I think the author is reaching when he suggests that chimps will develop labor unions. [There’s a cheap shot there, I just know it.]

Seriously, words fail. How is one supposed to engage in a debate with this? How does a letter like this become the counterargument to The Panda’s Thumb?

  1. It’s been my experience that the quality of argumentation is almost always negatively related to the tendency of your audience to agree with your position.

    Like it or not, most folks in the U.S. don’t believe in evolution.


    Drek    Jun 1, 12:14 PM    #
Name
E-mail (will be spam-armored)
http://
Message
  Textile Help