schussman.com logo

A Lightroom 2 workflow for the rest of us

(Welcome to readers coming via the nice link from the Lightroom team at Facebook! Consider checking out the rest of my Lightroom writing.)

—-

While Lightroom gets a lot of love from professionals who take a thousand photos at an event and need to manage a paying production workflow, it’s also great for enthusiast-level users like me: I usually work on the scale of a weekend’s or a trip’s worth of photos that need organization, a place to live, some pruning and keywords, and whatever sorts of RAW workup that’s necessary. Last week I wrote up a few general Lightroom tips with some vague intention of documenting a practical workflow; here are two high-level elements of my workflow: Import/File structure and metadata/keywords.

Import and file structure: I shoot in RAW and use Lightroom to import photos directly from the SD card via USB card-reader. Lightroom presents a number of options for storing those imported files: In the past I put imported photos in by-day folders, meaning one directory for each file date. So, for a handful of days’ worth of photos I’d have a hierarchy of directories like 2008-09-01, 2008-09-02, and 2008-09-03. I’ve recently switched to a storage option that, so far, I really prefer: I import photos to a single directory based on import date rather than file date, with a descriptive suffix to that directory. The nice upside to this approach is that a weeks’ worth of photos — a five-day trip somewhere, for example — all end up in a single directory, and can all be viewed and processed as a set (without having to put them all into a collection). Since Lightroom is so handy with metadata, I don’t lose anything by stepping up in granularity from by-day storage to by-import storage. Additionally, having fewer directories hanging around makes it easier both to backup and to browse my photo file tree with other applications.

Below is a screenshot to illustrate the import and directory naming stage:

Lightroom Import Dialog

On import, I assign a metadata preset and whatever keywords are applicable to the entire import set of photos.

After import is a first pass to identify picks and rejects and assign keywords, which I described last time around: Set grid mode to a large-ish preview size, and use shift-P and shift-X in grid mode to mark any clear favorites and rejects. After that pass, it’s keywording/metadata time.

  • Metadata: Lightroom has two-dozen or so non-keyword metadata fields that, frankly, I don’t have much use for. I tend to use only a few of them (in the “Image” metadata category) to assign geographic location of photos taken: I have metadata presets for common locations, and I assign the rest on an ad-hoc basis. At export time, some of this metadata is included as keywords, so my exported photos end up with, at least, city and state information attached.
  • Keywords: You can keyword forever in Lightroom. I start keywording with a single keyword set that broadly covers my most common uses (The “edit keyword set” function is accessed in the Keyword Set menu in the right-hand Keywording panel): I call this one “Common/Home”, and it contains, among other keywords, “Heather”, “dogs”, “flickr”, and “food” tags. I know the order of these tags and can quickly make assignments with alt-num combinations. With my “Common/Home” set active, alt-7 tags a photo with flickr, alt-8 with Heather, for example. Wondering what your common keywords are? Try exploring your database for common lightroom keywords, and take advantage of nested keywords and keyword hierarchies for the greatest efficiency in assigning keywords.
  • In Lightroom 2, the related keywords function adds a whole new dimension to commonly-used tags. Once you’ve assigned one or two from a preset menu (as above), you’ll get a set of keyword suggestions, as well. Lightroom 2 really does facilitate both identifying and applying keywords in a useful way.
  • On applying keywords: As with metadata, I’ve found it most useful to reduce the size of previews in the grid window and apply keywords in groups to a selected set of images first (as many as possible; ctrl-click (shift-click for a range) or shift-arrow with keyboard to select multiples), and then step through photos one-by-one, adding additional keywords as needed.
  • Lightroom lets you display keywords for a given image in a number of ways. I like to keep the keyword display set to “will export” — That’s generally the most complete display of the tags assigned to a given image, including synonyms and parents.

Possible items for next time? Super-basic RAW development, exporting, and collections: See my intro to RAW development!

  1. When you import RAW do you convert to DNG?


    Brian Zimmer    Oct 7, 02:58 PM    #
  2. I don’t convert to DNG on import, Brian. I don’t know if it’s rational or not, but I like to keep the original RAW format that my camera produces until I’m ready to move a given crop of photos to my backup drive. By that time, I’ve usually done whatever workup I’m going to do; I convert to DNG by folder, and then move the folder to the backup disk.


    alan    Oct 7, 03:44 PM    #
  3. One more question, you refer to importing into a directory named for the input date, which is also my preferred naming convention. However, in Lr2 I don’t see how to do this, it always wants to import to a directory named for the image date. What am I missing? Thanks!


    Brian Zimmer    Oct 7, 07:33 PM    #
  4. Brian — I added an image to the entry that shows how I do the importing. I hope it’s helpful. The short version is that LR doesn’t name the directory automatically; I put in the date and descriptive suffix on my own.


    alan    Oct 7, 08:04 PM    #
  5. Ah, ok. I also use Expression Media (I still find it’s tagging superior to Lr) and it can import by import date, a feature I felt was missing in Lr (still do apparently). Thanks for the screen shot, that definitely cleared it up.


    Brian Zimmer    Oct 7, 09:58 PM    #
  6. Great article! I’m looking forward for your basic RAW development tips!


    — Bruf    Oct 28, 08:00 AM    #
  7. Just found your web site – LOVE IT! I have probably the dumbest LR question ever. I store/work on all my photos on an external HD. Yesterday my computer crashed. I assume all my work is now lost. If so, how do you save your edits so you don’t loose them and if they are not lost – how do I access them? (I’m a LR novice, as if I even need to say that!)


    martie    Nov 14, 10:48 AM    #
  8. Hi martie, welcome!

    Lightroom stores all your edits to photos in your Lightroom library — the .lrcat file in LR2 — and keeps the photos themselves in the location where you import them. If your photos and library are both on the external hard drive, then they should be fine; plug the HD into another machine and recover/back up. However, if your library file lived on your PC that crashed, then it may indeed be lost. Try to recover that file using a disk recovery tool. Depending on the nature of the crash, you may be able to remove the HD and treat it as an external, non-bootable drive with another machine, giving you a chance to recover your files.

    Best of luck! I really hope your work isn’t lost.


    alan    Nov 15, 08:04 AM    #
  9. have you found any limits to the number of files LR2 can import and manage? Any limit to the size of the *.lrcat or preview.lrdata files?
    thanks!


    — steve    May 26, 06:20 PM    #
  10. Hi Steve-

    I haven’t hit a limit, but my catalog is relatively modest in size. I have heard of folks with catalogs in excess of tens of thousands of photos who do just fine.


    alan    May 26, 07:40 PM    #
  11. Hi Alan,

    Great blog (add’s to Google reader)… it seems that everyone has a lightroom workflow idea or post these days, and indeed a similar post is on my to-do list. Just wanted to say – great idea about using import date as the folder name. I currently use <year>/<country>/<large region or city>/<event> as I traveled a lot. Now that my little boy has arrived into this world, I am not travelling as much and the directory structure was becoming untidy without some order or date to line them up.

    I will now be “borrowing” your idea for this.

    Thanks again.

    Jonathan


    Jonathan Bourke    Feb 2, 09:52 PM    #
  12. Thanks for the visit and kind comment, Jonathan! You’ve got some really wonderful photos over at your site.


    alan    Feb 5, 06:05 PM    #
Name
E-mail (will be spam-armored)
http://
Message
  Textile Help